Sarah Rees leaning against a rock, looking thoughtfully into the distance.

VicForests accused of ‘spying’ on protesters and environmentalists


Sarah Rees had no thought she was being adopted.

On a morning like every other in 2011, she walked out of her house in Healesville, in regional Victoria, and began her automotive.

She drove to an workplace the place she ran a small conservation group, did a little bit of paperwork after which drove to Melbourne for the day.

Alan Davey says he was by no means far behind her.

For about 4 days, the skilled non-public investigator says he adopted her each transfer, on the request of a state authorities company.

“They instructed me they needed me to get as a lot grime as I presumably may on the girl,” Mr Davey says.

“I used to be of the understanding Sarah Rees was an individual of nice curiosity that VicForests was making an attempt to close up.”

VicForests is a Victorian authorities company tasked with supplying timber from state forests to sawmills and pulp mills across the state. It is run as a for-profit firm, owned by the federal government.

Nonetheless, the ABC can reveal VicForests employed a non-public investigator to conduct surveillance on conservationists and, extra lately, carried out what some have referred to as “digital surveillance” on folks the company argues are attempting to “discredit” it.

It is not simply conservationists who’ve been the goal of this work. An educational says he has additionally been the topic of digital surveillance by VicForests.

“Authorities businesses allegedly spying on their residents — there’s a actual query there whether or not that is lawful, whether or not it complies with our privateness legal guidelines, and whether or not it is per our rights below the Constitution of Human Rights that now we have in Victoria,” says Yusur Al-Azzawi, a senior lawyer on the Human Rights Legislation Centre.

The spy

A portrait of Alan Davey wearing an akubra-style hat, standing in the bush.
VicForests employed non-public investigator Alan Davey for different work in 2010.(ABC Information)

Alan Davey has executed all types of issues as a non-public investigator. He is tracked down stolen cattle within the outback, served courtroom paperwork on unwilling defendants, and uncovered dishonest spouses. A lot of it paid properly, he stated.

In 2010, he was employed by VicForests to tail logging vehicles and spot any contractors who have been driving dangerously.

A short news clipping describes how private investigators actions, including tailgating trucks, has sparked a debate.A short news clipping describes how private investigators actions, including tailgating trucks, has sparked a debate.
An article about Mr Davey’s work within the February 2010 Victorian Forest Contractors Affiliation publication.(Equipped)

He spent days and nights on roads by the Central Highlands of Victoria, filming vehicles hauling logs out of the forests, recording their speeds and registration particulars.

“There have been some rogue operators, for need of a greater phrase, that have been rushing. And their speeds have been harmful,” he stated.

Hours of video footage seen by the ABC reveals Mr Davey doing that work.

In 2010, employees caught wind of what was taking place, and objected to VicForests hiring non-public investigators to spy on contractors.

Nonetheless, Mr Davey’s work with VicForests did not finish there.

In 2011, Mr Davey claims he was instructed to give attention to a brand new goal: Sarah Rees.

“I would by no means met this girl earlier than, however I used to be deployed to do three to 4 days’ surveillance on her,” Mr Davey stated.

The topic

Sarah Rees looks into the camera with a serious expression.Sarah Rees looks into the camera with a serious expression.
In 2011, Sarah Rees was concerned with a marketing campaign to cease deliberate logging in Toolangi State Forest.(ABC Information)

By 2011, Sarah Rees had been concerned in forest conservation for a couple of decade, after she watched the water provide at Marysville degrade, one thing she says was attributable to logging.

However that yr, a marketing campaign kicked off over logging at Toolangi State Forest — simply 30 kilometres out of Melbourne — which, she says, raised the stakes.

After the 2009 Black Saturday fires burned 450,000 hectares of forest and killed 120 folks in close by Kinglake alone, VicForests noticed lots of their assets — state forests — disappear.

“Toolangi was thought of the inexperienced gap within the black doughnut,” Ms Rees stated. “It was burnt throughout and, as a consequence of freak climate, as a result of truth it is a wealthy, moist previous progress forest, it did not burn.”

Timber company to resume loggingTimber company to resume logging
In 2011, an environmental group campaigned to cease logging in components of the Toolangi State Forest.(ABC Information, File picture)

She says that meant each environmentalists and VicForests valued the realm — however for very completely different causes — and a marketing campaign involving protest exercise kicked off.

VicForests has frequently come into battle with protesters. However Ms Rees says the scenario in Toolangi, close to Kinglake, was an issue for them.

She says the protests lasted longer than common — about six weeks. And, she says, the help this protest had from the local people, in addition to its shut proximity to Melbourne, made it a fear for VicForests.

It was within the midst of that marketing campaign that Alan Davey says he was employed to comply with Sarah Rees.

The mission

Alan Davey squints through the viewfinder of an SLR camera with a telephoto lens.Alan Davey squints through the viewfinder of an SLR camera with a telephoto lens.
Alan Davey stated he didn’t discover any “grime” on Sarah Rees.(ABC Information)

Alan Davey says he met with a senior supervisor at VicForests, who defined what they needed: “grime”.

“[They said] ‘I need as a lot content material as you may presumably get. I need to know any s**t that she’s doing’ … and that is what I did,” Mr Davey says.

Mr Davey says he adopted Ms Rees for 4 days.

He took movies and images.

Mr Davey says he did not discover something of significance for VicForests.

“4 days of completely nothing,” he says. “Simply residing a really regular life.”

Ms Rees says VicForests noticed her as a risk as a result of she was utilizing the authorized system to problem their proper to log areas that have been essential to their enterprise.

“I used to be efficient,” she says. “I used to be utilizing the system that had been designed to carry them to account and … they have been searching for to wreck my standing.”

Nonetheless, she’s troubled by the surveillance.

“The reality of it’s it was bloody terrible to study of that,” she says. “I used to be shocked. I felt violated.”

She says she ceased the lease on the workplace she was utilizing, eliminated her mailbox and started utilizing a put up workplace field.

“I began performing in ways in which I usually would not. A level of paranoia crept in.”

An operation goes unsuitable

Alan Davey looks seriously at a laptop.Alan Davey looks seriously at a laptop.
Alan Davey stopped working for VicForests in 2011.(ABC Information)

Mr Davey’s engagement by VicForests to surveil protesters is confirmed in courtroom paperwork, together with sworn testimony by then-senior managers on the company.

Invoices present he was paid tens of hundreds of {dollars} for his work.

The courtroom paperwork additionally present all of it got here to an finish later in 2011, after a special spying operation went unsuitable.

In August, a VicForests supervisor met with Mr Davey, and requested him to conduct covert surveillance on protesters, together with taking images.

Sworn testimony by VicForests workers reveals that night, a VicForests basic supervisor of operations drove Mr Davey to the forest close to Toolangi to conduct his surveillance.

An bill seen by the ABC reveals he was paid greater than $8,000 by the federal government company for the mission.

The operation did not go properly. Mr Davey says he was detained by a number of folks and badly assaulted within the forest that evening.

He says he has no thought if the alleged assailants have been protesters, loggers or maybe even an organised crime syndicate which will have been utilizing the forest to develop drug crops, one thing that was identified to happen within the area.  

Mr Davey sued VicForests for damages and, in consequence, particulars of his employment can be found in courtroom paperwork. The case was settled out of courtroom.

VicForests did not reply to any questions in regards to the difficulty, however in a press release stated: “VicForests is at all times skilled in its dealings with each contractors, and those that do not help Victoria’s necessary timber trade. VicForests discovered no proof to substantiate claims by Ms Rees.”

Nonetheless, whereas Mr Davey walked away, VicForests’ pursuit of Ms Rees and others was not over.

The ‘file’

Sarah Rees says VicForests has continued to surveil her.

In 2019 and 2020, Ms Rees was deputy chair of the Australian arm of the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC).

It is a world not-for-profit that assesses merchandise made out of wooden for sustainability, and provides them a tick of approval.

Having that tick of approval is necessary for corporations corresponding to VicForests, since some prospects will not buy their wooden with out it.

Bunnings, for instance, has stopped promoting wooden from Victoria’s state forests for that very motive.

VicForests has tried a number of occasions to get FSC certification, however has repeatedly failed. 

“I believe VicForests is struggling challenges on many ranges with the attainment of the usual,” Ms Rees says.

In 2020, tales started showing in rural and trade media about some board administrators of FSC, together with Ms Rees, being “biased”.

The alleged bias of Ms Rees and different board administrators was so dangerous, in keeping with the experiences, that VicForests postponed its try and get FSC certification.

A number of of these tales reported a grievance VicForests lodged with FSC, calling for Ms Rees to be sacked.

The ABC has obtained that letter, and an related attachment, which Ms Rees describes as a “file” on her.

It incorporates an inventory of a whole lot of tweets, which VicForests alleged demonstrated her promotion of unlawful protest exercise and “actively searching for to discredit VicForests, a authorities company, and the Victorian authorities regulatory system”.

“It is a repeat of 2011,” Ms Rees says.

“This concept of surveillance on residents as a result of they do not like what we’re speaking about, as a result of they do not like us expressing a view.”

The grievance referred to as for Ms Rees and one other environmentalist, Peter Cooper, to be sacked.

They weren’t sacked, nevertheless Ms Rees says she was set to turn out to be chair of the organisation however withdrew her nomination due to all of the controversy.

In a press release, a spokesperson for FSC Australia stated Ms Rees “is a present and valued director”.

And it seems conservationists weren’t the one targets.

The scientist

Chris Taylor standing with his arms crossed in front of a section of logged forest.Chris Taylor standing with his arms crossed in front of a section of logged forest.
VicForests additionally referred to as for Chris Taylor to be sacked from the FSC board.(ABC Information: Michael Slezak)

The grievance additionally compiled the tweets and different public appearances of Chris Taylor, a forest scientist from the Australian Nationwide College.

Dr Taylor’s analysis has alleged VicForests has been engaged in widespread and systemic unlawful logging, a declare denied by VicForests.

“They roughly compiled a file of tweets that I made, articles that I’ve printed, analysis papers that I’ve printed and co-authored, and misrepresented them,” Dr Taylor says.

“It was fairly off-putting that they’d truly dedicate this time to surveil me in that regard.

“I believe VicForests sought to … take away my credibility, thereby my voice.”

FSC commissioned an investigation into the grievance. The ABC has obtained a replica of the investigation report.

It does not conclude that FSC board administrators did something unsuitable. Nonetheless it notes that the investigators have been “shocked by the response and escalation” to these actions.

“The allegations [of bias] have been investigated by FSC Australia and so they have been rejected,” Dr Taylor says.

Issues about ‘state surveillance’

Authorized consultants say each bodily and digital surveillance is worrying, particularly when executed by a government-owned company.

“State surveillance comes at a really excessive democratic value,” Ms Al-Azzawi says.

“Surveillance violates folks’s rights to privateness, and it has a very chilling impact on the train of political rights.

“I believe that this type of surveillance, the truth that it’s taking place in an unregulated surroundings, implies that we’re all in danger.”

Yusur Al-Azzawi looks into the camera with a serious expression while standing in an office.Yusur Al-Azzawi looks into the camera with a serious expression while standing in an office.
Yusur Al-Azzawi stated state surveillance comes at a excessive democratic value.(ABC Information: Michael Slezak)

Though the revelations closely impacted Sarah Rees, she says it hasn’t dissuaded her from her activism

“I do not suppose it is applicable for a authorities company to … behave like this. The federal government has an obligation and an obligation to handle its residents, to not surveil its residents, to not intimidate its residents,” Ms Rees says.

“I will not capitulate to the concern and intimidation and the ways they’re utilizing to silence us.”



Supply hyperlink

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: