Where Clive Palmer was wrong with his COVID vaccine claims

The place Clive Palmer was fallacious together with his COVID vaccine claims

Palmer: “It’s well-known that in case you’re vaccinated, you’ll be able to catch the virus, and you’ll cross it on. It makes no distinction in any respect from a public well being context.”

It’s true you’ll be able to nonetheless catch COVID-19 in case you’ve been vaccinated – as you’ll be able to nonetheless catch the flu in case you’ve had the influenza vaccine. However the coronavirus vaccine completely makes a distinction for the way unwell you’ll get, and reduces your potential to transmit it.

Melbourne’s ICUs are stuffed with critically ailing unvaccinated sufferers. The newest information from Victoria exhibits that 66 per cent of the 285 COVID circumstances in hospital usually are not absolutely vaccinated, whereas 74 per cent of these in ICU weren’t absolutely immunised.

In Sydney, unvaccinated individuals who caught the Delta pressure on the top of the outbreak have been 16 occasions extra more likely to find yourself in intensive care than their vaccinated counterparts.

Affiliate Professor Bette Liu, who co-authored an evaluation of the vaccination standing of circumstances in NSW, mentioned excessive vaccination charges have been “definitely going to cut back the burden of illness” from the circulating virus.


“The truth that we’ve seen reducing charges of illness via this outbreak as nicely, can be a sign of the impact of vaccines,” she mentioned.

Palmer: “Many individuals take the view that they might die in two or three years time as a result of unwanted effects usually are not simply if you take the vaccines.”

Really, unwanted effects for vaccines are pretty instant. The query of long-term unwanted effects is extra sophisticated – however in brief, scientists are assured the overwhelming majority of unwanted effects are found within the first few months after immunisation.

Scientists who’ve spoken to The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age say that is backed up by information on older vaccines, together with measles and the HPV shot.

As the pinnacle of Scientific Analysis on the Nationwide Centre for Immunisation Analysis and Surveillance, Professor Robert Booy, mentioned when discussing 10-year security information: “The perfect analogy is, now we have a dozen or extra routine vaccinations, for which we all know the long-term security profile is superb, and adversarial occasions which might be vital occur inside six minutes or six weeks of getting the vaccine.”

Palmer: “There’s coercion getting used on a regular basis: in case you’re a father, supporting 5 youngsters, your job is taken away by the federal government interfering, by Scott Morrison taking an motion, you’re shedding your livelihood.”

State’s management the well being orders and choices on vaccine mandates, and most have made vaccination a requirement for healthcare staff and aged care employees after nationwide cupboard settlement. Some states have additionally introduced in additional vaccination guidelines, requiring proof-of-vaccine for these eager to enter gyms, eating places or nightclubs.

However there’s a distinction between coercion – forcing somebody to do one thing – and making vaccines a requirement for doing sure issues, like working in a hospital with susceptible sufferers.

As Tasmanian Senator Jacqui Lambie mentioned earlier this week: “Should you’re in a position to get vaccinated however select not too, discrimination is the fallacious phrase.”

Her argument? Folks have the liberty to make selections, however generally, these selections have penalties.

“Being held accountable in your personal actions isn’t known as discrimination, it’s known as being, you wouldn’t consider it, a goddamn bloody grownup,” Senator Lambie mentioned.

Palmer: “Over 500,000 folks marched in Melbourne final weekend, 150,000 folks marched with Craig Kelly in Sydney.”


If Mr Palmer’s numbers have been right, it could imply one in 10 Melburnians had turned as much as the protest.

There have been giant rallies throughout the nation in protest over authorities restrictions and vaccines on November 20, however estimates of the group sizes have been all far decrease than claimed by the organisers and Mr Palmer.

NSW Police put the Sydney protest attendance at 10,000, and estimates of the Melbourne crowd put numbers at greater than 10,000 – definitely nicely brief half 1,000,000.

Keep throughout essentially the most essential developments associated to the pandemic with the Coronavirus Replace. Signal as much as obtain the weekly publication.

Supply hyperlink

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: